Sometimes people critique positive psychology for ignoring problems and therefore detracting from efforts to raise awareness and make change. As if highlighting how people are or can be happy despite adversity somehow validates or justifies their adversity. No, we are human beings, we are complex and nuanced, and positive and negative emotional states are mostly independent of one another. For example, someone can be burdened with the existential threat of climate change, and still go out with friends and feel happy. Someone else might find a sense of meaning and purpose through their work combating climate change. People have the capacity to understand that sort of nuance, because we all experience it, we all have positive and negative emotions every day. Sometimes we can laugh when we’re sad or cry when we’re happy. For that matter happiness is not as simple or as one-dimensional as it is often understood to be and might even be unique among individuals. In positive psychology, we try to understand the collection of experiences and emotions that make up a fulfilling life. As such I prefer the term wellbeing as a multidimensional concept including both objective circumstances (e.g., physical health and material conditions) and things like living a meaningful life, having fulfilling social relationships, as well as experiencing positive emotions. It does no good to represent Marshallese people as fully or wholly defined by climate change, colonial history, health issues, nuclear radiation, or any other challenges they face. In fact, what makes me love this place so much is how people know all those threats are lingering and still seem committed to being happy and kind and enjoying life.
I think people studying Marshall Islands from afar need to know what a beautiful special place it is and how wonderful the people are. At risk of contributing to the homogeneous view that I aim to disrupt, I will say this: Every single Marshallese person I’ve interacted with has been kind to me, many have been exceptionally friendly and welcoming, and some very quiet, but not a single person has been mean or rude, even when I fumble through cultural norms and communication challenges. Obviously, according to my identities (white, man, American, etc.) my experience is different and I have only interacted with a very small subset of the community, but still I do think there is a cultural emphasis on kindness. In addition to the fact that people seem genuinely happy (we’ll unpack the notion of happiness soon) it culminates in an overall very pleasant experience. Everywhere I go, I see people chilling out in the shade, smiling and laughing, kids playing, people just enjoying life. Also, maybe because I’m a foreigner, whenever I walk around people say hello, introduce themselves, ask about what I’m doing here; I never have that invisible, anonymous, disconnected feeling I have (and sometimes enjoy) walking around a big North American city.